Advanced Agents From First Principles 02: Why Does My Reasoning Agent Give a Different Answer Every Time? Use Self-Consistency Without Confusing Consensus With Truth

Sat, 08 Aug 2026 22:44:00 +0100

A reasoning agent gives you one answer.

You run it again.

It gives you another.

You change nothing important:

same task,
same tools,
same model family,
same broad context.

Yet the result changes.

That is not necessarily a bug.

A probabilistic model is allowed to produce more than one plausible trajectory.

The engineering question is different:

How should an agent system use that variation?

One common answer is self-consistency.

Agents From First Principles 02: AI Agent Gives Inconsistent Answers? Generate Multiple Candidates and Rank Them

Sat, 08 Aug 2026 15:54:00 +0100

One of the first things you notice when you build anything around a large language model is that the same prompt does not always produce the same quality of answer.

Sometimes the first response is excellent.

Sometimes it is merely acceptable.

Sometimes it misses the point entirely.

That creates a very common agent-engineering question:

If the model is inconsistent, should the agent trust the first answer it gets?

Often, no.

Self Consistency on Programmer.ie: Modern AI programming

Advanced Agents From First Principles 02: Why Does My Reasoning Agent Give a Different Answer Every Time? Use Self-Consistency Without Confusing Consensus With Truth

Agents From First Principles 02: AI Agent Gives Inconsistent Answers? Generate Multiple Candidates and Rank Them